By Phil Murphy, Co-Founder and CEO, Smart Outsourcing Solution
Is a flat EOR fee better than a percentage of salary?
A flat Employer of Record (EOR) fee can cost less for higher-paid employees. A percentage can cost less for lower-paid employees. For a mixed team, the answer depends on each person’s salary, how many months they work and where the provider applies its minimum. In the Philippine team example below, the flat fee totals US$5,700 over 12 months. The 10% quote totals US$5,280 without a minimum or US$6,000 with its US$160 monthly minimum per employee. That one clause changes which quote wins.
At Smart Outsourcing Solution (SOS), our standard Philippine EOR management fee is US$190 per employee per month and includes recruitment and candidate sourcing. I would give both bidders the same hiring calendar and ask them to price it. January’s invoice alone would point this buyer to the more expensive annual quote.
What do the two quotes cost over 12 months?
Illustrative January-to-December budget for one Philippine team. Quote A uses SOS’s published US$190 flat fee. Quote B is fictional: 10% of each employee’s monthly basic salary, subject to a US$160 minimum per active employee per month. The salaries are planning assumptions. Both quotes cover the same services in this example, with no other provider charges.
Two employees start on 1 January. The analyst receives a raise on 1 July, the same day an engineer joins. All starts and changes take effect on the first of the month. We use a fixed planning rate of PHP 60 per US$1 so that exchange-rate movements do not change the comparison.
| Employee and monthly basic salary | Billed months | A: flat fee | B: 10% before minimum | B: fee payable with minimum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coordinator: PHP 60,000 (US$1,000) all year | 12 | US$2,280 | US$1,200 | US$1,920 |
| Analyst: PHP 108,000 (US$1,800), rising to PHP 120,000 (US$2,000) in July | 12 | US$2,280 | US$2,280 | US$2,280 |
| Engineer: PHP 180,000 (US$3,000), joining in July | 6 | US$1,140 | US$1,800 | US$1,800 |
| Annual provider fee for the team | 30 employee-months | US$5,700 | US$5,280 | US$6,000 |
Read across the coordinator’s row first. Ten per cent of US$1,000 is US$100. The minimum raises the bill to US$160 each month, adding US$720 over the year. Even then, Quote B saves US$360 on that employee. The analyst costs the same under both quotes over the full year. The engineer costs US$660 more under Quote B, leaving Quote A cheaper by US$300 for the team.
What changed on the July invoice?
| Billing period | Active team | A: monthly fee | B: monthly fee with minimum | Provider fees for the period |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January to June | Coordinator and analyst | US$380 | US$340 | A: US$2,280. B: US$2,040. |
| July to December | Coordinator, analyst and engineer | US$570 | US$660 | A: US$3,420. B: US$3,960. |
Quote B starts out US$40 cheaper per month. In July, the analyst’s raise adds US$20 to B’s monthly bill. Adding the engineer costs US$300 a month under B and US$190 under A. Quote A is now US$90 cheaper per month. Its US$540 saving in the second half outweighs the US$240 it cost extra in the first.
What salary does the percentage apply to?
In Quote B, the fee base is monthly basic salary earned during active employment. It excludes bonuses, allowances, 13th-month pay and employer contributions. The table uses salary to calculate the fee. Salary itself, benefits, equipment, payroll advances and refundable deposits sit outside the provider-fee totals. Our guide to offshore salaries and provider fees shows where those amounts belong in the wider budget.
If a quote says “10% of gross payroll”, ask the provider to list the pay items it includes. For example, if the engineer receives a US$1,000 bonus and the contract includes bonuses in its fee base, the provider earns another US$100 that month. The same bonus generates no additional fee under the basic-salary definition used above.
The break-even salary in this example is US$1,900 per month (PHP 114,000 at the planning rate): 10% of US$1,900 equals US$190. Below that salary, B is cheaper given its US$160 minimum. Above it, A is cheaper. The analyst crosses that line in July, which is why using only the January salary understates B’s annual fee.
How should I compare the total provider fee over a year?
- Build one row per employee per month. Enter the billable start date, salary effective that month and any other pay the quote includes. For a mid-month start, use each provider’s written proration rule.
- Apply the fee at the level stated in the agreement. For each active employee-month here, A charges US$190. B charges the greater of US$160 or 10% of that person’s fee base. If the minimum applies to the whole account, calculate each month’s team fee first and then apply the account minimum.
- Sum the 12 monthly invoices and reconcile the result. Add any compulsory provider charges due during the year on separate lines. Ask each bidder to reproduce January, July and the annual total using your roster. Use the Philippines EOR quote comparison guide to check service inclusions, exclusions and billing currency.
The mistake I would look for in the spreadsheet is a single formula that multiplies annual payroll by 10%. Here, that produces US$5,280 and misses every month in which the coordinator triggers the minimum.
Frequently asked questions
Would a later start date change which quote wins?
Yes. Move the engineer’s start from 1 July to 1 October and keep the analyst’s July raise. Three fewer billed months reduce A by US$570 and B by US$900. The revised totals are US$5,130 for A and US$5,100 for B with the minimum. B now costs US$30 less. If that hire depends on a contract award, I would show finance both start dates before choosing a provider.
What if one provider charges separately for recruitment?
Get the actual recruitment charge for the hires you expect to make during the comparison year. Add it once per qualifying hire and label it separately from monthly administration. In the July-start example, the two recurring-fee totals are only US$300 apart. If A’s compulsory extras exceed B’s by more than US$300, B becomes cheaper overall.
Related Reading
- Philippines EOR Quote Comparison and Fee Normaliser helps you put competing offers on the same billing basis.
- Offshore Salaries vs the Provider Fee separates the employee’s pay, employer contributions and service charge.
- First-Year Offshore Hiring Costs vs Ongoing Costs takes you from the annual fee comparison to a funding budget that includes equipment, deposits and the first payroll.
Request a 12-month EOR fee comparison for your team
Send us the monthly basic salary and planned start date for each Philippine hire, the effective date of any raise and your billing currency. Request an itemised 12-month EOR estimate from SOS so your finance team can compare the provider fee, employee costs and upfront funding on separate lines.
About the author
Phil Murphy is Co-Founder and CEO of Smart Outsourcing Solution. He spent 12 years working in the Philippines, led operations of up to 10,000 employees and oversees SOS’s operations and service delivery.



