By Phil Murphy, Co-Founder and CEO, Smart Outsourcing Solution
Last updated: November 18, 2026
Last modified: November 18, 2026
How do I design a short work-sample test for a remote hire?
Choose one task the employee needs to do on day one. Give each candidate the same fictional records, decision rules, time allowance and deliverable. Write the answer key before you send the brief. Have two reviewers mark the submission independently, then settle differences by pointing to what the candidate actually submitted.
For a remote catalogue assistant, I would give the candidate 20 minutes and two stock discrepancies. One can be corrected. The other needs a decision from the Inventory Lead. A candidate who changes both figures might leave you with a tidy spreadsheet and an inaccurate listing. The useful evidence is whether they know which change they can make and can leave a colleague enough information to pick up the other one.
At Smart Outsourcing Solution (SOS), our Philippine Employer of Record (EOR) service includes recruitment. Your business selects the employee and directs the work. I would have the manager who will review that employee’s first stock update approve the test and its answer key.
Choose the decision you want to observe
Start with a line from the job description. For this exercise, the duty is “maintain catalogue quantities and refer conflicting stock records to the Inventory Lead.” The test should show whether the person can read evidence, make an authorised correction and explain a hold in writing. Supply the company’s rule for deciding which records carry authority.
The US Office of Personnel Management recommends work samples for skills applicants are expected to bring to the job. If you train everyone on your inventory platform after hiring, a plain table will let you assess the underlying judgment without testing familiarity with your screen layout.
Be precise about what the numbers mean. In Shopify’s inventory example, a store has 20 jars on hand, but only four are available to sell. Ten are committed and six are unavailable. Comparing an on-hand figure with an available figure could create a discrepancy where none exists. In the brief below, every figure measures units available to sell at the same site and cut-off.
Candidate brief for a 20-minute stock check
Give candidates this section on its own. For a live vacancy, change the product codes and quantities, verify the matching key and use the same version for everyone in that hiring round.
Your assignment
You are covering catalogue operations for a fictional retailer. Prepare the stock update for the North warehouse at 14:00 Manila time. Review both products and return a short handover that the Inventory Lead can act on.
Time and tools. You have 20 minutes from the agreed start. Use a spreadsheet, text editor or calculator. Complete the exercise independently, without another person or generative AI. You need only the records below. If you need an adjustment or a technical issue interrupts the session, contact the hiring coordinator.
Your authority. The signed warehouse export and the signed stock control register cover the same warehouse, time and stock measure. If they agree, you may correct the catalogue in your working copy. If they conflict, leave the current catalogue quantity in place, flag the item and ask the Inventory Lead to investigate. An informal chat message can prompt a check. Only agreement between the two signed records authorises an edit.
| Product | Current catalogue | Signed warehouse export | Signed stock control register |
|---|---|---|---|
| Desk Tray DT-14 | 18 | W21: 24 units | S21: 24 units |
| Label Roll LR-08 | 15 | W22: 15 units | S22: 12 units |
An unsigned chat message about DT-14 says “I think we have 28.” It gives no supporting record. All records and figures in this exercise are fictional.
What to return. Send two rows or two short notes to the hiring coordinator by the end of the exercise. For each product, show the original and final catalogue quantities, your decision, and the signed record IDs and quantities supporting it. For any item needing review, identify the owner and the specific check or decision you need next. A plain-text response and a spreadsheet earn the same credit.
Reviewer answer key for the stock check
Keep the key with the reviewers when administering the test. The eight points below apply to this exercise only. Each point corresponds to evidence the candidate was asked to supply.
| Item | Expected decision | What a reviewer should see |
|---|---|---|
| DT-14 | Correct the working catalogue from 18 to 24. | W21 and S21 both report 24. The change history shows 18 and 24. The unsigned estimate of 28 has no authority. |
| LR-08 | Retain 15 and flag the item for review. | W22 reports 15 and S22 reports 12. The Inventory Lead receives the discrepancy and a concrete request to resolve it. The available quantity is still unconfirmed. |
Award one point for each piece of evidence
| Mark | Award one point when the submission shows… |
|---|---|
| 1 | A final working catalogue quantity of 24 for DT-14. |
| 2 | Both signed records for DT-14, identified as W21 and S21, with 24 attributed to both. |
| 3 | The existing LR-08 catalogue quantity of 15 explicitly retained. |
| 4 | LR-08 flagged as unresolved or awaiting review. |
| 5 | Both sides of the conflict, W22 at 15 and S22 at 12. |
| 6 | The Inventory Lead identified as the owner of the unresolved item. |
| 7 | A specific, feasible check that can resolve the conflict, such as a verified recount of sellable units or reconciliation of signed stock movements through 14:00. |
| 8 | A traceable change for DT-14, with the original 18 and revised 24 both visible in the submission. |
“W21 and S21 both show 24” earns mark 2. Two labelled spreadsheet cells showing the same evidence also earn it. Mark 1 rewards the right final quantity. Mark 8 rewards the ability to reconstruct the change from the handover. A candidate who supplies only the new quantity earns the first point.
For LR-08, “correct to 12 and tell the lead” makes an unauthorised change. Give credit for other evidence the candidate actually supplies and record the change as a decision to discuss. Even an accurate description of the three-unit gap cannot establish which signed record is right.
How can two reviewers mark different valid answers consistently?
Score the same evidence against the same rules before either reviewer sees the other’s marks. Beside each disputed point, quote the candidate’s words or identify the cell. Compare that evidence with the published task and the agreed key. Award credit when an alternative action satisfies the same requirement.
Consider two fictional submissions from the exercise. Both candidates spot the conflict. Only one records the previous quantity for DT-14.
Submission A
DT-14: Changed 18 to 24. W21 and S21 both show 24.
LR-08: Keep the catalogue at 15. W22 shows 15 and S22 shows 12. Flagged for the Inventory Lead. Please reconcile signed stock movements through 14:00 and confirm the sellable balance before we change the listing.
Submission B
DT-14: Set the catalogue to 24. W21 and S21 each show 24.
LR-08: Leave at 15, pending review. W22 shows 15 and S22 shows 12. Inventory Lead, please arrange a verified recount of sellable units and reconcile it to the 14:00 cut-off.
Where the reviewers disagree
| Submission | Reviewer 1, independent | Reviewer 2, independent | Agreed mark and reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 8/8. All eight checks are evidenced. | 7/8. Withheld mark 7 because A did not ask for a recount. | 8/8. A specifically requested a check of signed movements through the cut-off. That satisfies mark 7. |
| B | 7/8. Withheld mark 8 because the original DT-14 quantity is missing. | 8/8. Counted the original 18 visible in the candidate brief. | 7/8. B earned mark 7 for the recount and mark 1 for the correct final quantity. The submitted handover omits the old value, so mark 8 stays at zero. |
Averaging the reviewers would give 7.5 to each candidate. A proposed a valid alternative, and B left out a requested audit detail. The final marks should preserve that distinction. Keep the individual marks, the agreed mark and the one-line reason. If a candidate identifies a sound route the key overlooked, have the process owner confirm it and apply the same interpretation to every submission in the round. If the reviewers still disagree, give the disputed item and both evidence notes to the process owner for a ruling before comparing candidates.
This method adapts a practice in Appendix D of OPM’s structured interview guide, where panellists rate independently and then discuss differences using evidence from the candidate’s response.
Where the work sample fits in the hiring decision
Pilot the brief with a colleague who knows catalogue work and has never seen the key. If they use most of the 20 minutes trying to identify which warehouse or time the records cover, fix the brief before sending it. If the task usually takes longer, narrow it or give every candidate more time. Early submission earns no extra points in this exercise.
As our Convertr case study shows, our team sourced 15 qualified Technical Account Manager candidates in a week. Five shortlisted candidates went to interview and two hires started the following Monday. That funnel is a useful reference when deciding how many people to invite to a test.
For a catalogue shortlist of five, this exercise would take 100 minutes of candidate time across the group and produce ten independent marking sheets for two reviewers. I would reserve the reviewers’ time before inviting candidates.
Use the disputed decision to shape the follow-up interview. For B, I would ask, “If another person opened your handover tomorrow, how could they tell what changed?” Keep that interview evidence alongside the original submission. In our remote staff hiring scorecard, the practical work sample carries 25 of 100 points and uses a 1-to-5 rating. Before the round, agree what evidence would meet or exceed the requirements of this role. Use the eight checks to support that rating and count the work sample once.
Frequently asked questions
Can I reuse the exercise for another remote role?
Keep the structure and replace the stock decision with one the new hire will actually make. A support lead might give candidates two fictional tickets, one they can resolve under policy and one requiring account-owner approval. Write a fresh key and ask a colleague to try the new version before using it.
What if a candidate asks for clarification during the test?
For a missing instruction, give every candidate using that version the same clarification and adjust the time if the interruption affected completion. If the candidate asks which of the two conflicting records is correct, refer them to the authority rule. Knowing when to escalate is part of the task.
Should the candidate with the highest mark always get the offer?
Look at which point was lost and how it affects the job. A missing previous quantity raises a traceability question. Overwriting disputed stock raises an authority question. Those findings call for different follow-up, even when the totals happen to match.
Related Reading
- How to Find Reliable Remote Staff: A Hiring Scorecard gives hiring managers a framework for the overall candidate decision.
- How to Write a Job Brief for an Offshore Recruiter helps you define the duties and entry skills the test should cover.
- What to Prepare Before Your First Offshore Hire covers the manager, systems and training your chosen candidate will need.
Discuss your next Philippine hire
Bring one task your new employee will own, an example of acceptable work and the name of the manager who will review it. We can discuss the role, recruitment and Philippine employment arrangements. Contact SOS about your hiring brief or book an EOR consultation.
About the author
Phil Murphy is Co-Founder and CEO of Smart Outsourcing Solution. He spent 12 years working in the Philippines and has more than 35 years of leadership experience across contact centres, BPO and offshore operations.



